Skip to content

This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Visit Our Showroom in St. Joseph, MI

Text or Call: 269.982.1188

Best-Selling Mattresses In-Stock

Rested Pillow Mattress
  • Mattresses
    • Pretty Green
    • Sunny Side Up
    • Nightcap
    • Sunny Side
    • Sleeping Bear
    • Way We Were
    • Bedder Days
    • Snoozefest
    • View All Mattresses
  • Sleep Match Quiz
  • Reviews
  • Accessories
    • Foundations
    • Signature Pillow
  • About Us
    • FAQs
    • Craftsmanship
    • Showroom
    • Our Story
    • Financing
    • Contact
  • Book An Appointment
Products
Pages
    0
    • Mattresses
      • Pretty Green
      • Sunny Side Up
      • Nightcap
      • Sunny Side
      • Sleeping Bear
      • Way We Were
      • Bedder Days
      • Snoozefest
      • View All Mattresses
    • Sleep Match Quiz
    • Reviews
    • Accessories
      • Foundations
      • Signature Pillow
    • About Us
      • FAQs
      • Craftsmanship
      • Showroom
      • Our Story
      • Financing
      • Contact
    • Book An Appointment
    • Search
    • Instagram
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    Open image lightbox
    Open image lightbox
    Open image lightbox
    Open image lightbox
    Open image lightbox

    Way We Were

    6 reviews
    Hand Tufted
    Flippable
    Made in Michigan

    Few mattress companies create two-sided, hand-tufted models anymore, but Way We Were proudly continues this traditional craft. Expertly built with both time-honored methods and advanced technological components, this firm mattress with dual sides that can be flipped will provide comfort and longevity for years to come.

    Best Pillow You'll Ever Buy

    Adjustable Natural Latex Pillow

    $149

    100 Night Comfort Guarantee

    Comfort Guarantee

    Financing Options Available

    Apply Now

    Product Specs

    • Traditional Firm Feel

      This is a firm mattress. Select Firm if:

      • You mainly sleep on your back or stomach
      • Are a side or back sleeper who require additional lumbar support
      • Are an above average weight and/or know you prefer a very firm sleeping surface
      • Recommended to you by a medical professional
    • Materials & Certifications
      • Flippable / 2-Sided
      • Hand-Tufted
      • Hand Quilted Cover
      • 1.8lb 25ILD Foam .375"
      • 1.8lb 32ILD Foam 1.5"
      • Bolsa® Pocket Coil w/Caliber™ Edge 8"
      • 1.8lb 32ILD Foam 1.5"
      • 1.8lb 25ILD Foam .375"
      • Coils: Twin-450 | Full-600 | Queen-736 | King-928
      • Handcrafted in Grand Ledge, Michigan

    • Dimensions

      Twin  | 39" W x 75" L x 13.5" H

      Twin XL | 39" W x 80" L x 13.5" H

      Full | 54" W x 75" L x 13.5" H

      Queen | 60" W x 80" L x 13.5" H

      King | 76" W x 80" L x 13.5" H

      Cal King | 72" W x 84" L x 13.5" H

      ** Due to our mattresses being handmade, these are approximate measurements and each finished product will vary within an acceptable tolerance as determined by the manufacturer.

    • Shipping
      • Shipping is free for addresses in the continental United States
      • Additional rates apply on all orders shipped to Alaska, Hawaii and Canada
      • We do not ship outside the U.S.A. and Canada
      • Barring any unforeseen delays, it typically takes 7-14 business days to build your mattress
      • Upon completion, it will be boxed and shipped to your doorstep in approximately 3-7 business days

    How They Used to Make 'em

    Flippable

    The significance of a two-sided mattress is that you can flip it regularly to prolong its comfort and durability. This is essential, offering consistent support for your spine for an extended span.

    Lasting Comfort

    Hand-Tufted

    Needle tufting is a time-honored technique dating back to the 17th century. By hand pulling ribbons through the mattress binding the layers together, it substantially improves comfort and durability.

    Hybrid Mattress

    Pocket Springs

    Features a low profile durable innerspring unit with tempered steel coils in multiple gauges, arranged in 2 ergonomic zones. It's reinforced with steel for max edge support, reduces motion transfer, & helps align the spine while reducing pressure points. It also sleeps up to 28% cooler than all foam mattresses.

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 6 reviews
    Write a review
    100%
    (6)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    S
    St. Joseph Boat Rentals
    We’re confident it will last longer than anything we could’ve ordered online

    Nick and Jen were absolutely amazing in helping us choose the perfect mattress for our 2-year-old daughter. We originally planned to buy one online, but decided to check out a local company first and we’re so glad we did! They went above and beyond, answering all of our questions and providing helpful insights we hadn’t even considered. Our daughter loves her new mattress, and we’re confident it will last longer than anything we could’ve ordered online. Thanks again, Nick and Jen!

    Hey, thanks so much! We’re confident it will last longer, too, and so glad she loves it. Appreciate you shopping locally with us, too. Stay Rested!

    A
    Anne Gain
    Have recommended to many!

    I have been so pleased with everyone at Rested Pillow! I have purchased several mattresses for my own homes and have recommended to many! It is always my first choice and will continue to be - the staff are extremely knowledgeable, not high pressure and so fabulous to work with! Many thanks to Rested Pillow!

    Thanks, Anne! You’ve been such a great customer and supporter of ours over the years. We appreciate you and your recommendations! We’re honored to be your first choice and get your great Rest. Take care and Stay Rested!

    L
    Lori Boettcher
    I LOVE this bed!

    I LOVE this bed! It's so comfortable and love the fact that Jenifer listened to our needs, and walked us through different mattresses and which to try before finding the one for us. The setup crew was amazing and friendly! Thank you, Rested Pillow!

    Thank you for sharing, Lori! Way We Were is a special mattress and we're happy you love it along with your entire Rested Pillow experience from the showroom, to delivery, to Resting each night. Stay Rested!

    A
    Ann Campbell
    Best mattresses

    For the price, I think these are some of the best mattresses in the area. They are made in Michigan, which is even better. The customer service and delivery were exceptional! I will definitely buy from them again.

    Thank you so much, Ann! We are very proud of our Michigan made beds and glad you are loving yours. We're thankful for your business and hope we see you again for future needs.

    M
    Maryann
    Great mattress I can flip

    I was looking for a 2sided mattress and it seems no one sells them anymore. Luckily Rested Pillow had the Way We Were and I love it. Not only can I flip it but it has the firmness I was looking for and feels amazing

    Thanks, Maryann! It definitely is a great bed and we're glad you love it. They don't make em like they used to, but we do!

    12

    About Us

    • Craftmanship
    • Showroom
    • Our Story
    • Our Reviews

    Mattresses By Size

    • Twin
    • Twin XL
    • Full
    • Queen
    • King
    • California King
    • All Mattresses

    Mattresses By Type

    • Customizable
    • Flippable
    • Hybrid
    • Mattress in a Box
    • Natural
    • Traditional
    • Pillow Top

    Mattresses By Firmness

    • Extra Firm
    • Firm
    • Medium
    • Plush

    Support

    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
    • Sleep Match Quiz
    • Blog
    • Exchanges & Returns
    • Warranty
    • Privacy Policy
    • Financing
    • Instagram
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • American Express
    • Apple Pay
    • Discover
    • Google Pay
    • Mastercard
    • Shop Pay
    • Visa

    © 2025, Rested Pillow Mattress

    Close